Analysing the top choice for the England job - and it's not Eddie Howe (2024)

Roll up, roll up, applications are now open.

On Friday, the FA quietly dropped its latest job post on the careers section of its website entitled: England Men’s Senior Team Head Coach.

You will need a UEFA Pro Licence and have, to quote from the application itself, significant experience of English football with a strong track record of delivering results in the Premier League and/or leading international competitions.


As it happens, it appears that the FA already have some candidates in mind. Lee Carsley, the England Under 21 boss; Mauricio Pochettino, Graham Potter and Eddie Howe, who already appears to be using the interest as a power play to get his own way at Newcastle.

So, who will it be? Mail Sport assesses the leading contenders.

Newcastle manager Eddie Howe is amongst the favoured candidates to become next England manager

Gareth Southgate's resignation following the Euro 2024 final defeat means applications are now open for his former job

Experience

HOWE: Took Bournemouth from League Two to the Premier League either side of a brief stint at Burnley before his move to Newcastle to lead the Saudi revolution, where he’s enjoyed his first taste of the Champions League. 7/10

CARSLEY: Learned his craft as a youth coach with Coventry, Brentford, Birmingham and Man City. No real first-team experience other than a few caretaker roles but has seen his reputation soar in charge of England Under 21s, leading them to their first European Championship since 1984.7/10

POCHETTINO: Far greater big-club experience than all the other candidates, having taken charge of Tottenham, Paris Saint-Germain and Chelsea after stints at Espanyol and Southampton. Knows what it’s like to play international football, too, with 20 caps for Argentina. 8/10

POTTER: His coaching journey started at the bottom. From the ninth tier in English football with Leeds Metropolitan University to Chelsea in the Premier League. Led small Swedish side Ostersund to three promotions and into the Europa League as well as a short stint at Swansea before working minor miracles at Brighton. 6/10

England Under-21 head coach Lee Carsley earned his craft as a youth coach with Coventry, Brentford, Birmingham and Man City but has no real first-team experience

Both of Chelsea's most recently-sacked managers Graham Potter (left) and Mauricio Pochettino (right) are both in the frame for the England role

Record

HOWE: No major trophy but Howe has undeniably enjoyed success with the resources he’s had. Three promotions at Bournemouth and turned a relegation-threatened Newcastle into a Champions League team who beat PSG 4-1 last season. Saudi riches help, of course, and it will be interesting to see how he’ll fare as the financial purse strings tighten. 7/10

CARSLEY: You can’t compare his senior record with his fellow contenders but he can boast something Southgate can’t. He’s brought England silverware. The Young Lions didn’t concede a goal throughout last year’s tournament. En route to Under 21 glory, his side beat Germany and Portugal, and even beat Spain in a final.8/10

POCHETTINO: A bit like Southgate, Pochettino gets beaten with a stick with the words ‘Yeah, but what have you actually won?’ scrawled on the side. I mean, he’s won the French league with PSG but everyone wins the French league with PSG. He’s lost two League Cup finals and a Champions League final.

In truth, Pochettino’s record is more than trophies. He develops players and shapes clubs. He even managed to turn Chelsea around before his untimely departure. However, only once in the history of the World Cup and Euros has the coach of the winning team not been from that country, when German Otto Rehhagel led Greece to the Euros in 2004. 8/10

POTTER: Again, a bare trophy cabinet. Potter’s success has always been more in his ability to develop players and get them to play in an attractive way that sees them punch above their weight. England punched above their weight in 2018 under Southgate. They are a heavyweight now and need someone to land a knockout blow. 6/10

Howe has never won a major trophy but has undeniably enjoyed success with the resources he’s had at both Bournemouth and now Newcastle

Pochettino isn't renowned for his silverware success either but is well-liked for his ability to develop young England players such as Cole Palmer (left)

Man-Management

HOWE: Players love to work for Howe but Anthony Gordon admitted that after joining Newcastle from Everton it took him six months to understand how he was supposed to play. Howe’s comments on Friday about Newcastle stank of politics, a world away from the statesmanlike behaviour we’re used to from Southgate. 6/10

CARSLEY: Carsley knows how to get the best out of attacking young talent. He had Cole Palmer in his Euros side alongside the likes of Gordon, Levi Colwill and Harvey Elliott. ‘This might be the best footballing team I’ve played in, in terms of how we play and the combination play around the box,’ said Gordon. ‘It’s really at an elite level. For me, that’s down to Lee.’ 9/10

POCHETTINO: England super sub Cole Palmer praised Pochettino for his skills at Chelsea, saying ‘he’s great at making you feel good’ and takes interest in any family issues.

At Tottenham, he was key to unlocking the potential of Harry Kane. He knows how to get the best out of him, something at which Southgate failed miserably at Euro 2024. 9/10

POTTER: Another manager who is renowned for connecting with the human side of his players. You’d hope so, too, having studied for a master’s degree in leadership and emotional management — even if he did once make his players perform a modern dance set to Swan Lake.

The question at Chelsea, though, was whether he was strong enough to deal with the big players and their egos. It’s one thing to manage Pascal Gross, it’s another to handle Jude Bellingham. 6/10

Carsley knows how to get the best out of attacking young talent as he has done so with England's youth team

Potter is amanager who is renowned for connecting with the human side of his players

Analysing the top choice for the England job - and it's not Eddie Howe (2024)

FAQs

Who are the candidates to replace Southgate? ›

Among the bookmakers' favourites are Newcastle manager Eddie Howe, former Chelsea bosses Graham Potter, Mauricio Pochettino and Thomas Tuchel, as well as Tottenham coach Ange Postecoglou.

Who are the contenders for England manager? ›

Newcastle boss Eddie Howe, former Brighton and Chelsea counterpart Graham Potter, Tottenham's Ange Postecoglou, ex-Liverpool supremo Jurgen Klopp and England Under-21s head coach Lee Carsley are among those to feature prominently in the bookmakers' odds.

Who is the new manager for England? ›

Lee Carsley has been appointed interim head coach of England senior men ahead of the start of the 2024-25 UEFA Nations League campaign.

Who are the candidates for England coach? ›

Jurgen Klopp, Eddie Howe and 10 candidates to succeed Gareth Southgate as England manager resigns following Euro 2024 final defeat
  • (C)Getty Images. Jurgen Klopp. ...
  • Getty Images. Eddie Howe. ...
  • (C)GettyImages. Frank Lampard. ...
  • Getty. Graham Potter. ...
  • Getty. Steven Gerrard. ...
  • Getty. Lee Carsley. ...
  • (C)Getty Images. ...
  • (C)Getty Images.
Jul 16, 2024

Is Southgate quitting as England manager? ›

In a statement, Southgate said it was "time for change" having managed the England team for 102 games. He first took charge of the Three Lions in autumn 2016.

Who is the bookies favorite to replace Southgate? ›

Graham Potter is the bookmakers' favourite to succeed Gareth Southgate after the England manager stepped down his role after Euro 2024 final defeat.

Who is the favourite for New England manager? ›

Next England Manager Betting Odds
SelectionOdds
1Lee Carsley3
2Graham Potter3
3Eddie Howe6
4Mauricio Pochettino9
6 more rows

Who will be the next England manager prediction? ›

Lee Carsley is a manager on the rise after guiding England's Under-21s to the European Under-21 Championships last summer while getting his crop playing an attractive brand of football. An in-house appointment could prove attractive to the FA after Southgate's success.

Who is the longest serving England football manager? ›

England lost to Brazil in the quarter-final of the 1962 World Cup in Chile and, under attack from the British press, Winterbottom resigned five months later. He remains the longest serving manager of England.

Who is the new head of England? ›

The Rt Hon Sir Keir Starmer KCB KC MP

Sir Keir Starmer became Prime Minister on 5 July 2024.

Who is the manager of the England men's senior team? ›

Lee Carsley is in line to take charge of the England men's senior team for next month's Nations League matches, as the FA continue their process to appoint a long-term successor to Gareth Southgate 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿👔

Who is the interim manager of England? ›

Lee Carsley has been announced as interim manager of the England men's football team. The 50-year-old is following in the footsteps of former Three Lions boss Gareth Southgate by stepping up from his role as coach of England Under-21s.

Who could be next England coach? ›

Perhaps a left field candidate but England Under-21 manager Lee Carsley is well thought of at the Football Association. He has been with the FA a long time and won the European Under-21 Championship last summer. He could potentially buy the FA time as an interim manager until a big name was free next summer.

Who is replacing England head coach? ›

England delays announcing permanent successor to Southgate and appoints Carsley as interim coach. England has delayed hiring a permanent coach to replace Gareth Southgate and will be led on an interim basis by Lee Carsley, who is currently in charge of the country's under-21 team.

Who were the England managers? ›

Ranked! EVERY England manager ranked from worst to best
  • England manager ranked from worst to best: 15. Steve McClaren (2006-2007) ...
  • Graham Taylor (1990-1993) ...
  • Sam Allardyce (2016) ...
  • Fabio Capello (2008-2012) ...
  • Don Revie (1974-1977) ...
  • Roy Hodgson (2012-2016) ...
  • Glenn Hoddle (1996-1999) ...
  • Ron Greenwood (1977-1982)
Mar 25, 2024

Who was England's last manager before Southgate? ›

Statistical summary
ManagerTenurePld
Stuart Pearce (caretaker)20121
Roy Hodgson2012–201656
Sam Allardyce20161
Gareth Southgate2016–2024102
16 more rows

Has Southgate ever managed a Premier League team? ›

After playing eleven games in their pre-season campaign, Southgate's managerial reign kicked off on 19 August 2006, the first day of the Premier League season, where his side lost 3–2 away at Reading.

Who did Southgate take over? ›

The match was Southgate's final appearance as a professional player. It was with Boro that Southgate had his first experience of management, taking over as boss in the summer of 2006 following the departure of Steve McClaren to take over as England manager.

What team did Southgate used to play for? ›

Initially a midfielder after coming through the ranks at Crystal Palace and captaining the Eagles to the old First Division title in 1994, it was following a move to Aston Villa a year later that Southgate first earned international recognition.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Trent Wehner

Last Updated:

Views: 5721

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Trent Wehner

Birthday: 1993-03-14

Address: 872 Kevin Squares, New Codyville, AK 01785-0416

Phone: +18698800304764

Job: Senior Farming Developer

Hobby: Paintball, Calligraphy, Hunting, Flying disc, Lapidary, Rafting, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Trent Wehner, I am a talented, brainy, zealous, light, funny, gleaming, attractive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.